Should your label say “May contain peanuts” because peanuts are used elsewhere in your kitchen? What if two products share a mixer, an oven, a fryer, or a packaging line? Is “Produced in a facility that also processes tree nuts” required, or does it warn about a risk that doesn’t really exist?
These questions are about allergen advisory statements, also called precautionary allergen labeling. They’re different from the allergen declarations required when a major allergen is an intentional ingredient.
In the United States, statements like “May contain milk” are voluntary, but they must be truthful and not misleading. They should communicate a genuine possibility of unintended allergen presence that remains after reasonable controls, not stand in for sanitation, segregation, production controls, or accurate ingredient labeling.
What Does “May Contain” Mean on a Food Label?
A “May Contain” statement tells shoppers that an allergen isn’t an intended ingredient but could be present because of cross-contact during ingredient handling, production, storage, or packaging. Examples:
- May contain peanuts.
- May contain milk and soy.
- Manufactured on equipment that also processes wheat.
- Produced in a facility that also uses tree nuts.
These are advisory statements. They don’t replace the ingredient list or the required declaration of allergens you add on purpose.
“Contains” vs. “May Contain”
The difference is whether the allergen is an intentional part of the food.
| Label Statement | What It Communicates | Typical Basis |
| Contains: Milk, Soy | Milk and soy are intentionally present | Recipe ingredients and sub-ingredients |
| May contain peanuts | Peanuts aren’t ingredients, but unintended presence is reasonably possible | Cross-contact assessment |
| Made on equipment that also processes peanuts | Equipment is shared with peanut-containing products | Manufacturing environment and controls |
| Made in a facility that also processes peanuts | Peanuts are used somewhere in the facility | Facility information, which may or may not reflect a real product risk |
“May contain” never replaces a required declaration. If milk is an ingredient, milk must be declared as federal allergen-labeling rules require.
For FDA-regulated packaged foods, the nine major food allergens are milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans, and sesame. For tree nuts, fish, and crustacean shellfish, the specific type or species must be named.
Is a “May Contain” Statement Required?
Not under federal FDA labeling rules. FDA describes allergen advisory statements as voluntary.
That doesn’t mean you can ignore cross-contact:
- Most FDA-registered food facilities must follow current good manufacturing practices (CGMPs), which include protecting food against allergen cross-contact.
- Facilities subject to FDA’s preventive controls rules must also evaluate allergen hazards and put appropriate controls in place.
- FDA says advisory statements should be used only after a manufacturer has followed good manufacturing practices and taken every precaution to avoid cross-contact. They’re not a substitute for those practices.
If you do use an advisory statement, you should be able to explain the actual cross-contact risk, the controls you use, and why some risk remains.
Other rules may also apply: state cottage-food laws, customer and retailer requirements, certification programs, and USDA rules for meat, poultry, and certain egg products. USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service allows factual statements such as “produced in a plant that uses peanuts” in limited situations where good manufacturing practices and effective sanitation can’t reasonably eliminate the risk. Confirm the rules that apply to your product.
When Might an Advisory Statement Be Appropriate?
When a documented evaluation shows a genuine, unavoidable risk that remains after reasonable preventive measures. For example:
- A complex piece of equipment can’t be fully disassembled, and validated cleaning can’t reliably remove allergen residue.
- Airborne flour, milk powder, or nut dust could reach exposed product nearby despite practical separation.
- A shared fryer or recirculated oil creates cross-contact between allergen-containing and allergen-free products.
- A supplier reports a credible cross-contact risk in an ingredient you use.
- Your process has intermittent cross-contact that scheduling, separation, sanitation, or dedicated tools can’t consistently control.
Shared equipment or a shared building doesn’t settle the question by itself. What matters is whether allergenic protein could reasonably reach the finished food after your controls are applied.
When Not to Use “May Contain”
To replace a required declaration. If an allergen is deliberately added, declare it in the ingredient list, a compliant “Contains” statement, or both. Never downgrade an intentional ingredient to a possibility.
As a substitute for cleaning or preventive controls. A warning doesn’t excuse poor sanitation, uncontrolled rework, inadequate storage, wrong labels, or careless scheduling.
Just because an allergen is somewhere in the building. A sealed peanut ingredient stored in a separate area is a very different risk from peanut flour used on the next line. A facility-wide warning that doesn’t consider how the allergen could actually reach the product may be unnecessarily broad.
To list every conceivable allergen. A blanket warning covering all nine major allergens may feel protective, but it can be misleading if there’s no reasonable risk. Overuse also narrows food choices for allergic shoppers and makes meaningful warnings harder to spot.
For an allergen you’ve already declared. FDA says an allergen declared as an ingredient shouldn’t also appear in an advisory statement. “Contains: Milk” plus “May contain milk” is misleading.
Next to a contradictory “free-from” claim. FDA’s guidance says you shouldn’t make an allergen-free claim and use an advisory statement for the same allergen, such as “milk-free” alongside “may contain milk.”
“Shared Equipment” vs. “Shared Facility” Wording
Labels commonly use several phrasings:
- May contain [allergen].
- Made on shared equipment with [allergen].
- Produced in a facility that also processes [allergen].
Shoppers often read these as different risk levels. They aren’t. FDA has explained that a “produced in a facility” statement isn’t necessarily different from “may contain” in how likely cross-contact is or how much allergen may be present. The wording describes circumstances; it doesn’t rank risk.
Choose the wording that truthfully describes the risk you identified. Don’t pick a facility statement just because it sounds less alarming than “may contain.”
How to Evaluate Cross-Contact Risk
Before adding an advisory statement, document a practical assessment of the product and process.
1. Map Every Allergen in Every Product and Ingredient
Include primary ingredients, compound ingredients, processing aids, toppings, rework, release agents, and supplier-provided materials. Check supplier labels and specifications, not just the ingredient’s common name.
2. Trace Where Allergens Travel Through the Facility
Follow each allergen through receiving, storage, weighing, staging, production, cooling, packaging, and rework. Include utensils, scoops, aprons, gloves, carts, dust collection, ventilation, and employee traffic.
3. Identify Realistic Cross-Contact Routes
Look for shared surfaces, incomplete cleaning, splashing, leaking containers, airborne dust, shared oil or water, misapplied rework, and wrong packaging.
4. Apply Preventive Controls
Depending on your operation, controls might include:
- dedicated tools or equipment
- physical or time-based separation
- allergen-aware production scheduling (for example, allergen-free products first)
- documented cleaning procedures
- cleaning validation and routine verification
- covered, clearly identified storage containers
- controlled rework practices
- line clearance and label verification
- employee training
5. Evaluate the Remaining Risk
With controls in place, decide whether unintended allergen presence is still reasonably possible. Record your reasoning, observations, cleaning results, supplier information, and any testing.
6. Reassess When Something Changes
Review your advisory labeling whenever you add a product, ingredient, supplier, room, process, piece of equipment, cleaning method, package, or rework practice.
Practical Examples
Intentional milk ingredient. A caramel sauce contains butter. Milk must be declared as an intentionally present major allergen. “May contain milk” isn’t sufficient.
Shared mixer with effective controls. A bakery makes peanut cookies and oatmeal cookies in the same mixer. If validated cleaning, scheduling, separation, and verification effectively control peanut residue, the shared mixer alone doesn’t automatically require “May contain peanuts.”
Hard-to-clean equipment. A confectionery line runs products with and without tree nuts. Product builds up in areas that can’t be reached, and cleaning can’t reliably prevent transfer. An accurate advisory statement may be appropriate while the business works to reduce the risk.
An allergen elsewhere in the facility. Sesame is handled in a separate enclosed room with dedicated equipment and storage. Automatically adding “Made in a facility that also processes sesame” to every product may communicate a risk the actual process doesn’t support.
Where Should an Advisory Statement Go?
FDA has specific requirements for “Contains” statements, but advisory statements have no standardized federal format.
In practice, make the statement easy to find and read. Placing it right after the ingredient list and any “Contains” statement lets shoppers review all the allergen information in one place. Use clear food-source names and consistent wording across your product line.
Don’t bury the statement in marketing copy or set it in hard-to-read type. And review the whole package to make sure nothing elsewhere, such as a “free-from” claim, contradicts it.
Using FreeFoodLabels.com for Allergen Labeling
FreeFoodLabels.com identifies major allergens intentionally present in your recipe and builds the ingredient statement and allergen declaration, which is the information behind a required “Contains” statement.
What a recipe can’t tell you is whether peanut dust travels between rooms, whether a mixer retains milk residue, or whether rework is properly controlled. A “May Contain” statement depends on your suppliers and your production environment, so it shouldn’t be generated from the recipe alone.
A sensible workflow:
- Build the recipe in FreeFoodLabels.com.
- Review the ingredient statement and the intentionally present allergens.
- Complete a separate cross-contact assessment of your facility and process.
- Add an advisory statement only if the assessment supports it.
- Review the complete label for clear, consistent allergen information.
You can build recipes and generate U.S. food labels with FreeFoodLabels.com for free, without an account. A free account lets you save your work and use recipe costing. Free labels include a “FreeFoodLabels.com” line at the bottom; unlock a recipe for $20 for unbranded labels and a recipe you can edit permanently.
Build your ingredient statement and allergen declaration
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a “May Contain” statement required?
Not under federal FDA labeling rules. Advisory statements are voluntary, but cross-contact still has to be evaluated and controlled, and any advisory statement you use must be truthful and not misleading. Other requirements may apply to certain products or jurisdictions.
What’s the difference between “Contains” and “May Contain”?
“Contains” identifies major allergens intentionally in the food. “May contain” warns of possible unintended presence from cross-contact.
Do I need a warning if I use shared equipment?
Not automatically. Consider the allergen, the equipment’s design, how effective your cleaning is, production sequence, rework, testing, and other controls. The decision should reflect the risk that remains after controls, not just the fact that equipment is shared.
Should every product from a shared kitchen carry the same warning?
Not necessarily. Products may use different equipment, areas, schedules, cleaning procedures, and ingredients. Assess each product and process instead of applying a blanket warning.
Is “Made in a facility” a lower risk than “May contain”?
No. There’s no standard risk ranking for these phrases, and FDA has noted that a facility statement isn’t necessarily different from “may contain” in the likelihood or level of allergen presence.
Can I say “peanut-free” and “may contain peanuts” on the same label?
No. FDA’s guidance says an allergen-free claim shouldn’t be combined with an advisory statement for the same allergen, because the two contradict each other.
Can I use “Contains: Milk” and “May contain milk” together?
No. If milk is declared as an ingredient, it shouldn’t also appear in an advisory statement.
Does a “May Contain” statement protect my business from liability?
It isn’t a substitute for required labeling, preventive controls, or accurate manufacturing records. Liability depends on the facts and the law, so get qualified legal or food-safety advice for your situation.
Can FreeFoodLabels.com decide whether my product needs “May Contain” labeling?
No. FreeFoodLabels.com identifies allergens from your recipe, but it can’t assess cross-contact in your facility. That requires evaluating your suppliers, storage, equipment, sanitation, scheduling, rework, and packaging.
Sources and Further Reading
- FDA. Questions and Answers Regarding Food Allergens, Including the Food Allergen Labeling Requirements of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (Edition 5) (January 2025).
- FDA. Food Allergies.
- FDA. The Current Food Allergen Landscape (source of the “produced in a facility” statement).
- FDA. Have Food Allergies? Read the Label.
- FDA. CPG Sec. 555.250: Statement of Policy for Labeling and Preventing Cross-contact of Common Food Allergens (2005), and the May 2023 draft update.
- USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service. Food Allergies: The “Big 9”.
This article provides general information about U.S. food labeling. It isn’t legal advice, a food-safety plan, or a product-specific cross-contact assessment. You’re responsible for evaluating your operation and making sure your labels are accurate and compliant.
